by OL » Mon Nov 14, 2016 5:51 pm
As always, every version of Ghost in the Shell is a completely separate entity, so I don't know why it should raise any eyebrows. There are bound to be references all over the place, even if the story is totally different.
I agree they've got some of the visual design work down. Nothing wrong with that stuff, really. It looks nice.
But I still take issue with the entire project regardless. I won't be able to get over the casting of a bunch of non-Japanese actors as Japanese characters, no matter how much they try to explain it away. You can say "she has an artificial body, so she doesn't necessarily have to look Japanese" all you like, but it still doesn't come off as anything other than a bullshit excuse. These characters all have Japanese names, yet they've got an American white girl playing Kusanagi, a Dane playing Batou, an Australian playing Ishikawa, an American white dude playing Kuze, and an African guy playing Boma. Even in the one instance where they actually hired an Asian person for one of the members of Section 9 (Togusa), they got a Chinese guy instead of a Japanese one. In a story so firmly rooted in Japanese society and politics, this is all just a bunch of politically-correct casting bullshit.
But that's all been said.
Looking at the trailer itself, I do have to say I'm weirdly disappointed that they've pretty much just lifted so many of the visuals from the Oshii movie. Practically 90% of the freakin' trailer is all just swiped from that one, solitary source. With so much Ghost in the Shell to pull from (the multiple comic series, the multiple tv shows, the multiple movies), it's odd that they seemingly decided to just lift from that one example.
Additionally, it seems like they've totally missed the point of the Ghost in the Shell mythos entirely. They seem to have turned it into some sterile, hackneyed, Hollywood crap about her being a new kind of android or something, instead of focusing on the undertones of individuality in a world totally connected by the net. Way to fuck that up.
Sure, it's not like I've seen the full movie or anything. Whatever. As much as I love the franchise it's inspired by, I'm just not digging what I've seen of this movie so far. The visuals seem nice, but it all just comes off as a shallow, westernized copy-and-paste job so far. Meh.