OL wrote: I absolutely adore the whole horror concept, but it's hard to name any movies that are actually scary.
^How true that comment is.
I actually find psychological thrillers to be more "scary" than horror movies. Movies in the same vein as "The Machinist" for example; They attempt to mess with your head, rather then try and scare you in an obvious way.
In terms of horror it really is difficult to pick out movies that are genuinely scary.
I would suggest a couple of movies that I really enjoy, "The Cube" & "Event Horizon". In all honesty, I love both these movies and I can watch them over & over.
Event Horizon Trailer:
Cube trailer: