If this has been asked previously then I apologise.
I have been thinking lately about whether Shenmue should have an in game map. I'm talking about the kind of map that you get in games like the GTA and Yakuza series. Where there is arrows to show points of interest and the next mission location.
Personally I am conflicted. On the one hand I have become accustomed to having the maps. I use them extensively in each of the games that offer them. I also think it would be used against the game if they did not include a map. Reviewers would claim that it shows how antiquated the series is, and it is not forward looking.
However, I also think that it would be contrary to spirit of exploration in Shenmue. I discovered a lot of cool things in Shenmue purely because I was forced to hunt around for things. With a mini map I admit I am likely to run from one location to another.
What say you Shenmue Dojo?